Hall of Fame question

[fatmenace]

I hear people all the time (I'm looking at you Mr. Justice) say that if you can't immediately decide if a player is a Hall of Famer, then that means he's not.

I'm not crazy for thinking that is completely asinine and irresponsible, correct?

[gk]

No you're not. Our best hope is that all the crusty BBWAA writers die off soon. Should be any day now for most of them....

[finkle]

i would say that you're right ESPECIALLY in today's overhyped era.

in fact, i think just because you automatically think of someone as a HOFer doesn't make them one.